|
|
Executive Summary of Findings
The purpose of the Nebraska LEAD (Leadership Education/Action Development)
Program is to provide promising adult men and women an opportunity to participate
in a two-year educational program designed to enhance the long-term future
of farming/ranching and agribusiness by developing future leaders.
Established in 1981 by the Nebraska Agricultural Leadership Council, Inc.,
the program purports to help participants develop an increased knowledge
of national and international economics and social change; a greater awareness
of organizational decision-making processes and the role of political institutions;
a greater sensitivity to the needs of society; preparation to deal with
issues impacting agriculture; and an overall broadening with the interrelatedness
of agriculture with other segments of our economy and world.
Nebraska LEAD Program officials have commissioned various follow-up
studies to evaluate the extent to which the program's purposes and objectives
have been achieved. Some studies have focused only on alumni of the Nebraska
LEAD Program and others have focused on three target populations. These
three target populations were asked a series of behavioral and attitudinal
questions from which comparisons were made. The three groups included:
Nebraska LEAD alumni who had completed the program; Nebraska LEAD candidates
who had been selected for entry into the program; and a random sample of
those who had applied for the program but not selected. By using these
three groups, conclusions were drawn about the effectiveness of the program.
Perhaps the most recognized program evaluation was conducted by the
Gallup organization which utilized the three-group approach. Although findings
of all studies have resulted in similar findings, the Gallup 'Executive
Summary' findings follow:
-
The Nebraska LEAD Program helped participants feel a greater commitment
to persist in an agricultural occupation. Among alumni, 89 percent expect
to be in an ag-related occupation five years from now and 17 percent are
currently considering an occupational change. Seventy-six percent (76%)
of those not having the Nebraska LEAD experience expect to be in an ag-related
occupation in five years, and approximately one-third were considering
an occupational change.
-
Nebraska LEAD Alumni were more active in a greater variety of organizations,
particularly ag-related organizations. Further, they were more likely to
be officers in those organizations and to devote more time participating
in organizational activities. Nebraska LEAD Alumni were significantly more
likely to be asked to speak to larger groups, both in terms of size and
variety, than were those who had not been through the program.
-
The attitudes of Nebraska LEAD alumni were significantly different than
either new program enrollees or non-accepted applicants on the following
factors:
A. Economics -- Alumni have a more cosmopolitan
understanding of agricultural economies. They were much more likely to
recognize that the ag-economy differs little from the economics of other
industries.
B. Agricultural Policy -- Alumni were much less parochial
in their attitude toward the formulation and effect of policy. They were
more likely to feel ag policy was reflective of urban sensitivity to farm
issues.
C. Farm Organizations -- In addition to much greater involvement,
alumni were significantly more likely to be supportive of farm organizations
and more positive in their view of their effectiveness.
D. Nebraska Legislature -- While there was no statistically
significant difference in the attitude of the three groups on this factor,
there was a clear trend for Nebraska LEAD alumni to be more understanding
of the legislature's sensitivity toward agricultural needs.
E. Honesty -- Alumni were broader in their view that others
outside of agriculture were as likely to be honest as those involved in
agriculture.
F. Foreign Policy -- Although the differences were not
statistically significant, there was a convincing trend that alumni feel
those involved in agriculture were reasonably well informed on foreign
policy.
-
There were no significant differences among the three groups surveyed on
the factors of social responsibility, the need for education for agriculture,
or the future of agriculture.
-
Nebraska LEAD Alumni overwhelmingly endorse the program.
A. Ninety-six percent (96%) would strongly recommend
the program to others. Not one participant indicated they would not recommend
the program to others.
B. Seven out of ten report they have become more active in agriculture-related
activities since their involvement in the program.
C. Ratings of selected parts of the Nebraska LEAD Program were unusually
high. Of particular benefit to participants was the opportunity to meet
others, continued interaction with other participants, the study/travel
seminars and discussion at seminars. Rated slightly lower were the speakers
at seminars, but this item still received a very high rating.
D. There were no consensus recommendations for improving the program.
Many use descriptive terms like 'great educational program', 'fantastic
experience', etc.
In the opinion of the evaluators, there was convincing and compelling evidence
that Nebraska LEAD Alumni had a broader view and a deeper perspective of
the factors affecting agricultural economics and policy than did those
who had not had the Nebraska LEAD experience. They tend to be more understanding
of the wide variety of influences on society in general and agriculture
in particular. They show evidence of being more tolerant of those not directly
involved in agriculture, and they seem to appreciate more the relationships
that exist between agriculture and other career orientations. They appear
to be more sensitive to national and international issues, and there was
evidence of a greater general awareness of the role of agriculture in the
world community. Nebraska LEAD Alumni were more active as leaders in ag-related
organizations and activities. They were entremely positive about the Nebraska
LEAD Program and attribute it with encouraging them to become more active
in leadership roles.
In the words of the researchers "by the measures of this research effort,
the researchers can say with confidence that the purpose, goals and objectives
of the Nebraska LEAD Program are being achieved and gratitude is expressed
with respect to the cooperation and professionalism shown by officials
of the Nebraska LEAD Program."
Return to the Nebraska LEAD home page.
|